Protection for Life

Personal Insurance

Auto Insurance

Home Insurance

Vacation Homes

Waterfront Homes

Rental Homes

Jewelry & Collections

Antique Auto




Commercial Insurance

Business Owners Policy (BOP)

General Liability Insurance

Commercial Auto Insurance

Workers Compensation

Professional Offices

Fuel Oil Dealers







Life & Health




Long Term Care



Insuring your cars, homes and businesses for over 90 years

The Roy H Reeve Agency has been protecting local friends, neighbors and businesses against the inevitable bumps and bruises of life since 1926. The Agency was founded on a philosophy of offering personal, professional service.

As an independent agent, we combine products provided by the most respected insurance providers into a custom package that meets your personal or business needs.

When you request a quote, we work hard to find discounts that apply to you — multi-car insurance if you insure multiple cars with us, for example, or combined car/home insurance discounts. Our goal is always to give you the coverage you need at the lowest possible price.

Our Main Office is located on Long Island's North Fork in Mattituck, NY.  We are large enough to serve you, yet small enough to care. 

Affordable Car & Vehicle Insurance

Vehicle damage is a fact of life. Trees fall on them, rocks crack their windshields and even the most careful driver is involved in traffic accidents from time to time. Roy Reeve not only insures damage to your vehicle and passengers, but the damage you may do to other vehicles, property or individual(s).

Home & Property Insurance

The urge to protect our homes, the place where we lay our heads and raise our children, is universal. The Roy Reeve Agency helps keep the castle safe and sound with comprehensive coverage that guards against theft, fire and storm damage.

We also insure other properties, including apartments, condos, mobile homes and property owned by your business. Ask your agent for a quote.

Complete Business Insurance

If you own a business, you’ve got enough on your mind without worrying about what will happen if an employee is injured on the job or your roof is damaged in a storm.

The Roy Reeve Agency helps you minimize your risk with a comprehensive array of products designed just for business: general liability, workers compensation, group health insurance – even special coverage for home businesses.

For more information about our firm and the services we offer, send us a quick email or call our office. We welcome the opportunity to speak with you.  |  (631) 298-4700